| Author | Message | ||
| Peter Johnson (Astraz)
|
Are they going to have a street party ? | ||
| manoj rane (Manojrane)
|
is weather relevent? If one of them did not throw it out, would other one benifit more? If they dont do this, will they suffer loss? will they both gain same amount of benifit? Or they could compete with each other for more gain? Is the even man-made, or natural? Could these two peopl have ever expected this to happen? Or it is a lifetime surprise event for them? Is furniture made of wood? Fire relevent? Is time of the event relevent? | ||
| miroac (Miroac)
|
Is it relevant how Bill "investigated"? Did he go over and talk to Sal? and then decide what Sal was doing made sense, so he copied? Is specifically what Sal saw and heard relevant? Was it something on TV? a commercial? a news broadcast? These third person(s)... 1 person? 2? more? relatives of Bill? of Sal? neighbors? Did Bill and Sal know these person(s)? know them well? Would these other(s) have wanted the furniture in the street? Would they care? | ||
| Simon Downham (Beroean)
|
Is the act of throwing furniture important in itself? Is there anything else tangible that is relevant? Is the location significant? Has anything changed or happened recently at the location? | ||
| Ixoye724 (Ixoye724)
|
Are they going to have a street party? No is weather relevent? Yes If one of them did not throw it out, would other one benifit more? Possibly If they dont do this, will they suffer loss? No will they both gain same amount of benifit? Yes, safe assumption Or they could compete with each other for more gain? No, likely not Is the even man-made, or natural? I don't think I understand this q...ask again Could these two peopl have ever expected this to happen? Or it is a lifetime surprise event for them? Elements of the situation are probably new to both people Is furniture made of wood? No Fire relevent? No Is time of the event relevent? It may help you slightly to know this Is it relevant how Bill "investigated"? Did he go over and talk to Sal? and then decide what Sal was doing made sense, so he copied? Yes to all Is specifically what Sal saw and heard relevant? Yes Was it something on TV? No, BUT... a commercial? No a news broadcast? No, but explore this one These third person(s)... 1 person? Yes relatives of Bill? of Sal? neighbors? See next answer Did Bill and Sal know these person(s)? No, had never met them know them well? No Would these other(s) have wanted the furniture in the street? Yes Would they care? Yes Is the act of throwing furniture important in itself? Yes, at least I would say that it is Is there anything else tangible that is relevant? Yes Is the location significant? Yes Has anything changed or happened recently at the location? YES | ||
| miroac (Miroac)
|
This other person-- let's say C. standard q's: human? adult? living? male? Do they expect the furniture to stay in the street? Do they expect C to know that their furniture is in the street? Do they expect C to interact with the furniture in some way? use? move? take? destroy? Do they expect to see or meet C? The furniture is made of or contains... plastic? metal? wicker? fabric? glass? Is the current weather relevant? or something that is going to happen? rain? storm? tornado? Are they tossing all they're lawn furniture? or some that meet a certain criterion? Does it matter? Did Sal see or hear something on the internet? radio? ham radio? | ||
| miroac (Miroac)
|
Are they tossing all | ||
| manoj rane (Manojrane)
|
Is the event man-made, or natural? I mean, situation is result of human activity or natural thing? By throwing furniture out, are they making room for something that can go on lawn? Is something being thrown/felling that will break if it hits furniture, but not break if it falls on lawn? Could they benifit by throwing furniture in say basement/underground room, rather than throwing it on road? What if they hadn't had any furniture on lawn - would they still benifit? or benifit comes from throwing? Benifit from throwing furniture only? Benifit from throwing something else (due to no furniture) like say used tyers/boxes? | ||
| Simon Downham (Beroean)
|
Any of these relevant: Wind? Hurricanes / Tornadoes? Volcanoes? Earthquakes? Fire? Rain? Snow? Hail? Is the physical relationship between the street and the lawned gardens relevant? Are it materials that the furniture is composed of relevant? Is there anything happening (other than the furniture throwing) that could be percieved as surreal? | ||
| Ixoye724 (Ixoye724)
|
This other person-- let's say C. standard q's: human? adult? living? Yes to all male? Or female, doesn't matter Do they expect the furniture to stay in the street? No Do they expect C to know that their furniture is in the street? Yes Do they expect C to interact with the furniture in some way? I'd say not use? move? take? destroy? No to these Do they expect to see or meet C? Yes-ish, you may want to re-phrase this q The furniture is made of or contains... plastic? Yes metal? wicker? fabric? glass? None of these Is the current weather relevant? Yes or something that is going to happen? This as well rain? storm? Yes to these, but there is another way to describe this weather tornado? No Are they tossing all they're lawn furniture? Possibly, keep reading... or some that meet a certain criterion? Yes Does it matter? Yes Did Sal see or hear something on the internet? radio? ham radio? Probably not any of these Are they tossing all their lawn furniture? Not relevant, just to know they are throwing some of it Is the event man-made, or natural? Actually both of these are applicable, but the major part of the event is natural I mean, situation is result of human activity or natural thing? Again, both factors apply but mostly natural By throwing furniture out, are they making room for something that can go on lawn? No Is something being thrown/felling that will break if it hits furniture, but not break if it falls on lawn? No, N/A Could they benifit by throwing furniture in say basement/underground room, rather than throwing it on road? No, that would not produce the desired result What if they hadn't had any furniture on lawn - would they still benifit? NO (good question) - if they hadn't had lawn furniture they most likely would not have benefitted at all or benifit comes from throwing? Well part of it, yes Benifit from throwing furniture only? Benifit from throwing something else (due to no furniture) like say used tyers/boxes? Boxes certainly could have been thrown if they met certain criteria, but these two guys will 'benefit' (and be careful how you define this word) because of the type of furniture on their lawn Any of these relevant: Wind? YES Hurricanes? YES Tornadoes/Volcanoes/Earthquakes/Fire/Rain/Snow/Hail? None of these Is the physical relationship between the street and the lawned gardens relevant? I don't think so Are it materials that the furniture is composed of relevant? Yes Is there anything happening (other than the furniture throwing) that could be percieved as surreal? I would say not | ||
| Simon Downham (Beroean)
|
Is the thought here that the Hurricane would suck up the furniture and blow it onto the house causing damage or risk to the inhabitants? | ||
| Ixoye724 (Ixoye724)
|
Is the thought here that the Hurricane would suck up the furniture and blow it onto the house causing damage or risk to the inhabitants? No | ||
| Simon Downham (Beroean)
|
Was the Hurricane already upon them? Or was it just brewing? relevant? Is there something else that we need to know about the: Street? Furniture? Lawns? Houses? location? People? Hurricane? Other? | ||
| Ixoye724 (Ixoye724)
|
Was the Hurricane already upon them? Yes, and... Or was it just brewing? This was the case as well relevant? Yes Is there something else that we need to know about the: Street? No Furniture? No Lawns? No Houses? No location? No People? Yes Hurricane? Yes Other? Yes | ||
| miroac (Miroac)
|
Does the 'benefit' involve affecting the hurricane somehow? stopping or slowing it? affecting it's course? Is the color of the furniture relevant? This other person, can we give him a name? Joe? Is the furniture a signal? to Joe? that they need rescuing? | ||
| Tim A. Dowd (Bodo)
|
Insurance relevant? FEMA? | ||
| Ixoye724 (Ixoye724)
|
Does the 'benefit' involve affecting the hurricane somehow? No stopping or slowing it? affecting it's course? No to both Is the color of the furniture relevant? No This other person, can we give him a name? I don't see why not Joe? I suppose that name will work Is the furniture a signal? No to Joe? No that they need rescuing? No Insurance relevant? FEMA? No to both | ||
| Eliot (Eliot)
|
Are they only tossing furniture made of plastic? Do they want the hurricane to take the furniture? To move it? To blow it over? Relevant where in the world they are? Is the hurricane actually going to come through their area? | ||
| Tim A. Dowd (Bodo)
|
Do they hope the hurricane will remove the furniture for them? Send it to anywhere in particular? Are they sort of "acting" as a hurricane themselves? Will they blame the hurricane for throwing the furniture into the street? | ||
| Ixoye724 (Ixoye724)
|
Are they only tossing furniture made of plastic? Yes Do they want the hurricane to take the furniture? Not really To move it? Yes To blow it over? Yes Relevant where in the world they are? No, it's been established that it is an area where hurricanes occur Is the hurricane actually going to come through their area? Well........explore this one | ||
| Ixoye724 (Ixoye724)
|
Do they hope the hurricane will remove the furniture for them? No Send it to anywhere in particular? Strictly speaking, yes Are they sort of "acting" as a hurricane themselves? Yes, on the right track Will they blame the hurricane for throwing the furniture into the street? No, they won't... | ||
| Eliot (Eliot)
|
Will they ever retrieve the furniture? Do they want it to go somewhere nearby? In the same neighborhood? Are they making it seem as if the hurricane came through although it didn't? |
