by CoffeeBean » Tue Aug 04, 2020 3:05 pm
Did Carl take two objects from Liam? 3-5? 6-10? More than 10? The exact number isn't known, but let's say 4-6 objects (but FA here too)
Were all objects the same? similar? part of a set? Yes to all
Relevant how he felt about the objects? Not really Had he wanted to keep them? No Was he happy to get rid of them? No
Relevant what Carl did with the objects after taking them? It may help you determine the situation if you explore this
Did anyone see the taking? Yes Did the people who laughed at the response see it happen live? No
Hear about it? Read about it? Some may have but likely very few
Did Liam’s response involve moving his body in a relevant way? Yes Interacting with an object? No Making sounds? No
Did the response cause bodily harm to Carl? Yes
Did the response indicate that Liam was angry? upset? Both sad? disappointed? surprised? confused? impressed? relieved? happy?
Did they only become famous in 2013? Before that? They were famous long before 2013
so maybe what they did became famous thanks to someone else? E.g. it was reproduced in a tv show? Yes to both of these in a movie? Later, yes in a YouTube video? I'm sure it has By someone famous? Well, yes In a spot/advertising? It's probably been done but this isn't the main format Maybe it was reproduced and adapted to modern times? No Technology relevant? In part, yes
Did Carl take Liam's objects without permission? Without asking him? Neither of these apply
Did Liam expect it? No Did Carl made a joke to Liam? No Were the objects the same kind of object? Yes Different types of object? Are they usually found in houses? Yes Clothing? No Are they still present nowadays? Yes
Did the objects belong to Liam? Maybe or maybe not, this is unknown (and relates to the FA mentioned above) Relevant what they were? Yes Pieces of paper? Yes but there's more to it than that Documents? No
Keys? cigarettes? medicines? food? Wallet? Musical instruments? a collection? This, in a way charges? batteries? munitions? glasses? Tickets?
Is the fact that they were brothers relevant? Yes, because of other undiscovered events
If so, because only brothers could know where the objects were? No, not because of this Is info sharing relevant? No
Technology of the time? Only to a secondary degree Relevant the work of the two? Yes Was it the same? Yes
Did they entertain people? Yes oleography relevant? Acting? Yes to this Dancing? Magic tricks?
Was Liam's response verbal? behavioural? Both, but the behavior is most relevant. --> was Liam's response voluntarily exaggerated? Or it was spontaneous? It was both spontaneous and to some degree exaggerated
did he expect that Carl would have taken his objects? He may have expected it, yes Did Liam accuse Carl? Likely that he did, yes
Did Liam fall in desperation? No Try to find the objects? He didn't need to do this Look for them in a comic place (e.g. in his clothing but by doing it he made something relevant that made people laugh)? No
Look for them in a comic way (e.g. Carl took his glasses and he look for them by not seeing anything)? No
Were the two in a relevant place? Yes, something about the place is relevant
Did Liam notice that someone (Carl?) took something as soon as Carl took the objects? Yes Did Liam react immediately? Yes