by Hobbsicle » Sat Dec 12, 2020 11:27 pm
hominid
Is the thing that Grandma lived through a historical event? It's not an "event", but it is something broadly experienced an event in her life? a specific year? No Would it work if Sophia was preparing a playlist for some other person she knew who was around Grandma's age? Yes, all else the same
Is it relevant when the Greek songs were released? No Were they released during Sophia's lifetime? irrel, but yes during Grandma's lifetime? Were the songs tied to the thing that Grandma lived through? No Was the band tied to the thing that Grandma lived through? Yope, in a lateral sense, but only the name is relevant Did they have a connection to the other music that was in the playlist? Yes, a connection to every other thing on the playlist
Earnest
Now that I look at the names James Taylor, Joni Mitchell, and Carole King...I know they make something together right? Don't remember what but I think they were close...or connected somehow. Relevant? Not relevant, I knew James Taylor and Carole King had some connections, wasn't sure about Joni Mitchell. I just picked some people of the same vein, who were decidedly not death metal.
Link between the death metal artist and every other song included on the playlist --> death metal artist = HAF? Irrel, but they're a group of HAM lyrics relevant? titles of the song? No to both Position of the death metal song in the playlist (e.g. when the grandma hear the death metal song she has to turn the CD...)? Is every other song played with relevant instruments? Improvised? Having a relevant solo? irrel to rest
To be sure, can we assume that the death metal band was more recent than the the songs in the album? It was, yes, though the time period of the death metal isn't really relevant I mean it formed more recently...if so, relevant precisely when? Was it the opening band of relevant concerts? Were the songs included all live? Has the Greek band been always unknown? I mean...maybe they were very known and decay after a relevant event...relevant? irrel to rest Would the grandma immediately recognize the link between the death metal song and the other songs? Good question, I would say not likely at first, but she might suspect the link if she thought about it a bit
WAG --> a song of the death metal band and a song of the composers were in competition in a relevant event. The death metal group's song was so criticized that the song of the three emerged in the event making them famous (i.e. they became known thanks to the failure f the greek band) No
Is every other song in the playlist part of the same album? No
Was the grandma famous? Was she a singer? No or irrel
Did Sophia live relevantly near the grandmother? Not technically relevant, but it would make more sense if she did...--> because she would have heard the songs? Because she would have helped the grandma? Yes-ish to both of these two, her physical presence is relevant Does the grandma hear the songs with headphones? Relevantly without? Relevant? No
WAG2: the songs are just base tracks. The grandma loved to play both acoustic and electric guitar. While the songs in general do not contain guitar solos but only chords, the death metal song contained a solo which could fit in any of the other songs. No